Let me say right off the bat that I never read Stephen King’s short story, “The Boogeyman” so I don’t know if this short film by Irish filmmaker Gerard Lough is a faithful adaptation or not. In THE BOOGEYMAN (which has a 27 minute run time) Andrew (Simon Fogarty) is talking to psychiatrist Dr. Harper (Michael Parle). Andrew and his wife Rita (Joanne Cullen) have had three children die mysteriously and Andrew is trying to get off his chest that he knows The Boogeyman, who lives in the closet, is responsible for killing them. The entire short takes place inside the psychiatrist’s office and we get flashbacks to some of the events that led Andrew to his present situation.
Right off the bat we get the feeling that Andrew is a pretty troubled guy who’s been carrying around a lot pent-up hostilities and stress. Through his flashbacks we learn Andrew works a job he doesn’t particularly enjoy, he’s worn out and tired from having small children, and his married life isn’t as exciting as he’d like it to be. Is this Boogeyman just an extension of his stressed out and fractured psyche or is it real. Lough does a good job straddling that fine line and keeping the viewer guessing until the final scene.
Lough does a nice job telling the story and creating a nice tense and creepy feel. Many of the scenes have a bluish hue to them and Lough utilizes a lot of really interesting camera angles that helps create a very mysterious atmosphere. The two things this short lacks is action and shots of the creature. Most of the action, as I mention above, occurs in flashbacks but it would’ve been more interesting if more of the story took place in real time. The actual Boogeyman itself doesn’t get too much screen time, and what we do see of it isn’t too impressive. It looks like a mask bought at the local Five and Dime store. But overall Lough crafts a solid narrative that keeps the viewer guessing as to the truth behind Andrew’s story: Are Andrew’s children dead as a result of a cracked psyche or is there actually a Boogeyman? He keeps us guessing until the final seconds of the short. This is a well-made short and I recommend it.
Director: Gerard Lough (& screenwriter)
Plot: 3 out of 5 stars (could use more action)
Gore: 0 out of 10 skulls
Zombie Mayhem: 0 out of 5 brains
Reviewed by Scott Shoyer
What’s more difficult than making a unique and solid horror film? Making an effective horror-comedy that works and one which the comedy doesn’t overshadow the horror. When the horror-comedy hybrid is done right it can be a whole lotta fun. Just take 2004‘s SHAUN OF THE DEAD; this is the near perfect horror-comedy if there ever was one. Well now we can add Ryan A. Levin’s THE FIFTH (which has a run time of 14 minutes) to the list. THE FIFTH is a simple enough set-up: Five guys leave behind their girlfriends and wives to get together for their weekly poker game. Brian (Rob G. Kahn) is the new guy to the group and they all get along. Sam (Simon Anthony) is the real poker-lover of the group and he’s getting a little pissed that Ken (Sam Lloyd) is running late.
Finally Ken shows up but he’s not alone; he’s dragging behind him a dead woman (Nicole Surels) by the hair. Very nonchalantly Ken apologizes for being late but he was raping and killing the woman and lost track of time, “So I didn’t have time to bury her.” The rest of the group explains matter-of-factly to Brian that Ken is a serial killer and he’s also their friend. Brian is pretty freaked out but listens to them. But suddenly the “dead” girl bolts upright screaming and Ken flips out, bashing her head in against the table and slitting her throat. None of the other guys (except Brian) bats an eye. It’s a hilarious scene that is one of those rare moments in a genre film where you want to laugh but feel really uncomfortable doing so because let’s face it, a woman is being brutally murdered. Very well done!!
Amidst all the violence Brian gets the hell outta there and runs off. This sets off Sam because all Sam wants to do is play poker. The guys are pissed at Ken not because he’s a serial killer (“we love and support you no matter what you decide to do”) but because they can’t keep a fifth player … Ken keeps killing them. They want Ken to stop “bringing his work” to the poker games. So in perhaps the funniest line ever, Ken stands up, looks genuinely sorry for continually interrupting the weekly poker game and then makes a solemn promise:
I’ll tell ya what; I’m gonna hunt down Brian, kill him, come back here, fuck his corpse in the bathtub and from that point on work is work and poker is poker.
Absolutely hilarious. The short then ends with the guys at the poker table trying to figure out who they can invite next week to make the fifth poker player.
Sure the comedy does outshines the horror here, but the writing is so well done that you’re gonna have a lot of fun with this short. The writing is crisp and funny, the scene of Ken re-killing the girl is violent and bloody, and the acting (especially from Sam and Ken) is fantastic. Here’s the link to THE FIFTH below. I’d love to hear what you think about it!! I highly recommend it.
Director: Ryan A. Levin (& writer)
Plot: 4 out of 5 stars
Gore: 1.5 out of 10 skulls
Zombie Mayhem: 0 out of 5 brains
Reviewed by Scott Shoyer















































